Updated · GizmoCue Editorial Team

How to choose watch straps and bands

Compare watch strap and band sellers on fit, lug width, materials, watch compatibility, support and the countries they serve before you buy.

What a strap or band changes

The strap decides how a watch feels and how it looks. A new one can make an old watch comfortable again, suit it to a different occasion or give a smartwatch a style of its own. People buy straps for wear and tear, for a change of look, for sport, or because the one in the box never fitted well. A strap is also one of the easier parts to replace, which makes it a simple way to refresh a watch.

The first step is to know what you are replacing. The wrong size or the wrong fitting is the main reason a strap does not work. Look at the watch itself, at the old strap and at the manual, and write down the details before you start browsing.

Fit, lug width and fitting type

A traditional watch has two lugs, which are the arms that hold the strap on. The strap fits between them, so the distance between the lugs, called lug width, must match the strap. Measure it, or look it up for your model, and match it exactly. A strap that is slightly too narrow looks loose, and one that is too wide will not go in.

Check the fitting type. Spring bars are the usual pins, and many straps come with quick-release bars that let you swap straps without a tool. Smartwatches often use their own connector, made for the exact case size and model. Check the model name and the case size on the product page. A strap for one generation of a smartwatch may not suit a later one.

Materials and comfort

Leather has a classic look and softens with wear, but it does not like water or heavy sweat. Silicone and rubber suit sport and swimming. Metal bracelets are durable and formal, but need links removed or added to fit. Nylon and woven fabrics are light and dry fast. Think about how you wear the watch, and match the material to it. A strap for the office, one for the gym and one for a holiday can be different, and many people keep a spare.

Check the length as well as the width. A strap that is too short or too long for your wrist is awkward, so measure your wrist and read the length notes. Look at the buckle or the clasp, and at how many holes or adjustment points it has. If you have sensitive skin, look at the materials listed on the product page.

How 123watches NL, BandsCo, Barton Watch Bands and Wristr differ

123watches NL serves the Netherlands, lists watch straps and phone cases, and offers support by email and chat. BandsCo lists watch straps and serves the US. Barton Watch Bands also lists watch straps and serves the US.

Wristr serves Germany, lists watch straps and offers support by phone and email. The stored facts are limited, so check each seller’s own pages for the watch models it covers, the materials and the fitting types.

What to check before you buy

Read the return window, since fit is the main risk. Check who pays to send a strap back and whether it must be unworn. Look at how the seller states compatibility, and whether it gives lug widths and model lists. Photos on a wrist and close pictures of the clasp and the stitching help you judge the build. A seller that publishes sizes clearly is easier to trust than one that does not.

Check that the seller serves your country. Look at the support channels, and at whether someone can answer a question about your watch before you order.

How to shortlist

Write down your watch model, the lug width or the smartwatch case size, and your wrist size. Decide on the material and the style you want. Keep sellers that serve your country and list your watch. Compare the return window and the support for the two or three that remain. The watch straps and bands comparison shows more sellers side by side. If you are still choosing a phone to pair with a smartwatch, read the guide to smartphones.

See the full ranking: Top watch straps and bands compared →

Sources